Broken Herringbone QAL 28


The famed Molli Sparkles is hosting the Molli Sparkles Broken Herringbone QAL (MSBHQAL for short..er), and he asked me to write a bit about the inspiration for the block and give some tips and tricks to share with you all. Of course I’m happy to oblige!

Violet Craft’s booth at Quilt Market – Picture by ImAGingerMonkey

Background

The initial inspiration for the block came from a quilt in Violet Craft‘s booth at Quilt Market 2012, made to mimic the design of one of her Madrona Road fabrics. The quilt pattern was not available at the time (it is available now, here!), but I fell in love, HARD. I was in a block swap, and wanted to create a block reminiscent of the fabric and quilt, so I decided to give it a shot.

This is the first tester block I made. You may notice that I didn’t line up the center triangle, and it left me with these little itty bitty bits on the bottom corners. When I posted the shot to my group, one of my hive mates said that she would prefer that the blocks didn’t have those. So in subsequent blocks, I lined up that center triangle which alleviated those itty bitty bits.

Other than that, the block design didn’t change much from the original design. I’ve seen comments that the block construction is “clever”, but I assure you it was all serendipity and a desire to be thrifty with my fabric. I wanted to use the remnants since my first strips were so long, and I noticed that with the way they were cut, they nicely fit later in the block. It was a happy find, but definitely not pre-conceived!

 

Tessellation

Quilt and photograph by Marianne (Adventurous Quilter)

I’ve thought a bit about how to tessellate this block (have the pattern repeat seamlessly) and it seems like there are two ways you could go about it. The first is to start with longer strip sets (WOF), and just keep throwing more strip sets to the end. This will lead to a long row of broken herringbone. I believe that is what Marianne did here.

herringbone

If you are still interested in making the herringbone as blocks, it looks like a block that is 12.5″ x ~14.75″ will give you the length-wise repeat. (Rotated to fit in the blog better.)

herringbonetessellate

 If you want longer or shorter blocks, you want to trim based on right-most corner of the strip sets on the left (strip sets on the top in this rotated version). Any of the dotted lines shown above are where you could consider a seam line for your block for a repeat.

herringbonetrim

 

Because you are matching a lot of points, I’d suggest not cropping to exact block measurements, but rather measure .25″ out from where you want the blocks to meet. For instance, you need .25″ above the top triangle, and .25″ below the rightmost corner of the left strip set to make them line up correctly when they’re sewn together. The seam line is shown as a dotted line above.

 widthrepeat

For a width-wise repeat, you can move a row of blocks up or down so they line up to the row next to them, or extend the right side of the block by another ~ 1″, making it 13.5″ wide, but the triangle in the center is 1″ off center.

Color Variations

mosaic6f2e9dcfd13d6255f729e29858091dc28060559f

When I designed this block, it was for a block swap. Each person asked for two or three colors + sashing color, and they received one block with those colors. Because of that constraint, all the blocks I’ve created with the pattern were created with that in mind. It wasn’t until Molli’s rainbow quilt version that I realized that there are obviously more options!

With thin sashing (.5″ in these examples) or using the tessellation approach above, the blocks work together to create a cohesive design, as opposed to feeling like stand-alone sections. When the blocks read together, there’s some fun things you can do with color and contrast to bring out different shapes within the pattern. I made a couple of mockups that play with that correlation and carry the color through neighboring blocks to show some of the variations possible with the block.

rainbow2

 

The first follows the colors vertically throughout each block. This gives the illusion of a continuing herringbone without having to worry so much about lining things up.

rainbow

The second uses similar colors between blocks, which brings out the chevron shape of the block. This looks a bit like trees, or overlapping geese.

zigzag

The third would be even more apparent if you uses the tessellation approach, but by carrying the color throughout strip sets across blocks, you can see a zig-zag pattern emerge. This almost looks like choppy water.

There are tons of other possibilities as well! Shapes are created by areas of lower contrast, and edges defined by areas of higher contrast. Keeping that in mind, you can play with color placement and color contrast to create different shapes within the pattern, as well as rotate the blocks to get even more looks!

Here is the link to a .pdf file that contains just the herringbone outlines, which you can print out and use to color in your own design ideas!

I look forward to seeing what everyone does, and I hope this gives you some food for thought!

-Anne

 

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

I love comments, and respond to each one!

28 thoughts on “Broken Herringbone QAL

    • anne Post author

      <3 You rock!! And you should totally do the QAL! In all that spare time you're totally going to have over the next couple months. :D I really want to do the "choppy waves" version after making these mock ups.

    • anne Post author

      So many projects, so little time! I understand! 😀 I hope you have a chance to come give it a try when you have more time. 🙂

    • anne Post author

      Block interaction is just something on my mind lately, so it was the first thing I thought of when Molli asked me to do a post. 🙂 I am so excited to see all the blocks showing up in the flickr group! So fun! I hope someone gives some of these patterns a try. (Mostly because I want to see how they look in something other than a sketch. lol)

  • Sue

    An interesting post, its given me some things to think about but I think I will have to re-read it after I have made at least one block so it makes more sense to me!

    • anne Post author

      It is a lot all at once, I admit! Hopefully it’s more clear after you’ve made a block. If not, please feel free to ask questions, I’d love to help with any problems you might face!

  • mary

    Hi Anne – thanks for the pdf, will help me plan out for the QAL and use fabric from my scraps bin! One question, I think the pdf a mirror image of the finished block? It seems reversed…thanks

    • anne Post author

      Hahaha I spelled it every way BUT the right way when I was making that post. Thank goodness for spell check! 🙂
      Now that I’ve finally done all the math, I really need to go about making one of these!

      Also, someone pointed out that these are all reversed. So I should probably fix that, too. Oops.

    • anne Post author

      I think I may try the choppy waters version for the QAL! Although it means it’ll be harder to re-use the strip sets unless I plan it well between blocks. 🙂 I’m on it!! lol

    • anne Post author

      I think I’m going to try one of these layouts as well. 🙂 I’m sure it will add some interesting challenges to making the blocks, though!

  • Stacey@thetiltedquilt

    Thank you for the info! I’ve done 6 blocks and I keep getting those little flippy corner things in the bottom – so it’s because I’m not centering my top triangle as I should? I have trimmed but maybe I’m missing something. In the end, I think it will be ok and will likely be lost in the seam allowance, so I am not too worried. Thanks so much!

    • anne Post author

      I went to your blog to check your blocks, they’re gorgeous!! What size are you trimming down to? These look bigger than 12.5″ which is what I trim mine to. If you trim it down to 12.5″ square, the little flippies should go away! 🙂 I hope that helps!

  • Tina

    Oh Anne! You are so talented! I popped over here just to see all the lovely things you do and every time I do, I am reminded of how you are able to do so many things and do them so well. You inspire me. 🙂

    Tina

  • Am L

    Hi Anne. We’ve met once or twice at Julie’s shop, but this block is the first playcrafts tutorial I’ve tried. I’ve joined Molli’s QAL, and I love this block! A big thank you for sharing with us, and I’ll definitely play with the PDF.

    • anne Post author

      Oh how exciting!! Next time I’m there, please say hi so I can put name to face. 😀 I really need to get back over there, but it’s always a little hard on my wallet. 😉
      I’m so glad you are joining the QAL, and I can’t wait to see your blocks and quilt!

    • anne Post author

      Man that swap was so long ago!! Someone else in the flickr group is rotating the blocks, and it makes this really cool diamond shape. That’s my working favorite, but I’m totally fickle.